Review: ELF Waterproof Eyeliner Pen

I'm not sure if I just got a bad batch, but this pen was so dry and there was no color pigmentation. I give this one a big thumbs down. Good thing it was only $1.

Color                 1/5

Creaminess        NA

No smudging     6/10

Longevity          5/10

Value                3/5

Rating: 15/30 F

This is when I tried to use it. You can see the faintest black line on the top lid.